Eyebrow pencil is not something I use – if I want to define my eyebrows, then I brush some brown eye shadow on them. I find this works well, but if you want to use eyebrow pencil, try Couleur Caramel Eyebrow Pencil, $31.99. It comes in three colours – Blond, Light Brown, and Dark Brown.
Eyebrow pencil is not the only option. Bare Escentuals has a brow kit, which consists of bareMinerals Brow Color (which is a powder), Angled Brow Brush, and Brow Finishing Gel. I think it’s about $85.